Not every NFL team in need of a new head coach will find immediate success in this hiring cycle. Teams are hoping to land a coach like Ben Johnson, Mike Vrabel, or Liam Coen, who turned their franchises around in a short time. But that’s no guarantee.
While it will take time to evaluate the success of the 10 teams that hired new head coaches, we can grade them based on initial impressions. We’ll also assess the most high-profile coordinator openings.
This post will be updated with each new hire.
Head Coaching Hires
New York Giants: John Harbaugh
Securing John Harbaugh was the best possible move for the Giants. It’s their most significant hire since Tom Coughlin in 2004, and they will be hoping for similar results.
Harbaugh brings a career win percentage of 61.4% and a Super Bowl title. Though his recent playoff performances have been underwhelming, the Giants have struggled even to make the playoffs. With the likes of Ben McAdoo, Joe Judge, and Brian Daboll preceding him, Harbaugh represents a fresh start and a proven leader.
With a solid young core, Harbaugh raises expectations for a team in need of direction. Over 18 seasons in Baltimore, he had just three losing campaigns, and while the Giants may not experience instant success, this hire is the best they’ve made in years.
Grade: A+
Atlanta Falcons: Kevin Stefanski
Kevin Stefanski is a rare coaching talent, having earned NFL Coach of the Year honors twice. The Falcons seized the opportunity to hire him, knowing how well he navigated tough quarterback situations in Cleveland.
Stefanski steps into a favorable situation: a talented roster and a weak division. If he can get solid quarterback play, the Falcons have the potential for a significant turnaround. Given his track record in Cleveland, this hire looks like a great fit.
Grade: A
Miami Dolphins: Jeff Hafley
The Dolphins landed Jeff Hafley after his successful tenure as the Green Bay Packers’ defensive coordinator. While the Miami job comes with challenges, including the likely departure of quarterback Tua Tagovailoa and salary cap issues, Hafley’s experience should help him navigate this rough patch.
With his previous head coaching experience at Boston College, Hafley is familiar with the pressures of leading a team, and he’ll work closely with new general manager Jon-Eric Sullivan, a former Packers executive. While this may be a transitional year, Hafley has the tools to succeed in the long run.
Grade: B
Tennessee Titans: Robert Saleh
Despite a disappointing stint with the New York Jets, Robert Saleh is regarded as a strong defensive coach and a leader. His work with the San Francisco 49ers’ defense last season re-established his reputation, and now he heads to the Titans, who have struggled in recent seasons.
Saleh’s defensive prowess will be an immediate boost for Tennessee, but his success will depend on the offensive staff he assembles. How he develops the Titans’ offense, especially with the No. 1 pick in the upcoming draft, will be crucial for his long-term success.
Grade: B+
Coordinator Hires
Detroit Lions Offensive Coordinator: Drew Petzing
Drew Petzing arrives in Detroit with a solid reputation, although his tenure as the Arizona Cardinals’ offensive coordinator didn’t yield great results. The Cardinals ranked 19th, 11th, and 19th in total yards over his three seasons, though subpar quarterback play and injuries were significant factors.
Petzing’s connection with former Lions coordinator Ben Johnson and the opportunity to work with a talented Detroit offense could be key. Despite the underwhelming numbers in Arizona, the Lions’ offensive talent gives Petzing a better chance to succeed.
Grade: B-
Los Angeles Chargers Offensive Coordinator: Mike McDaniel
Mike McDaniel’s appointment as offensive coordinator for the Los Angeles Chargers is a potential game-changer. McDaniel, who was a top head coaching candidate, will take over a Chargers offense loaded with talent, led by quarterback Justin Herbert.
With McDaniel’s creative play-calling and a healthy offensive line, the Chargers have the makings of a top-five offense next season. If McDaniel can unlock the full potential of the roster, the Chargers could become one of the league’s most dangerous teams.
Grade: A
